January 13, 2012
I’ve recently picked up a crime fiction novel that I’m now reading on my kindle. It is from a first-time writer, and I was eagerly looking forward to reading it and praising it to all and sundry.
Unfortunately it sucks.
The core of the book is sound – at least as far as I can see – but it is clear that while it has (one hopes) gone through some author-led revisions and tunings, it is still a first draft – perhaps even a pre-first draft. The language is repetitive, the scenes are framed badly, the language is stilted, and there are questions to be raised regarding character motivation and how that relates to not only the situations in the novel, but also the ability for the characters to emotionally express themselves.
As a result of this above melange, I’m not going to mention the name of the book or the author on this blog – but I will say that while I find the book to be subpar it is a strong reminder of the following:
- Even if you self-publish, an editor is critical
- A first draft is never the finished work (unless you are a robot from the future, in which case “welcome!”); you should always write, re-write and write some more. A first draft is the expulsion of the words from your mind. You are as likely to write a new draft from scratch as you are to rework the draft in front of you.
- You need both an alpha and a beta reader group – alpha to help highlight the faux pas (this work is at alpha reader stage in my opinion), and beta a few more revisions down the line – to help gauge whether the content/internal promises in your novel are being met.
As per my firing up my personal blog: I’m writing a novel, and I’m writing some non-fiction works. I’m not only a big fan of writing, but a big fan of supporting those who write. I will shout to the heavens those new authors that I come across whose work I love. I will even review books that I didn’t enjoy, but I will do so in a measured and just manner. I cannot however review this current work. It would be like kicking a puppy with live kittens strapped to my feet.
I will however purchase his next work (should there be one), because I’m like that. After that, I’ll have no problems reviewing one way or the other.